Is Pranami sector being criticized?
Greetings (Pranam) everyone. This is a blog that is dedicated to address issues happening currently in the Pranami community around the entire world.
Instead of simply
demanding a simpler answer to that question (on the title), why not we ask - what
had led to those people to criticize at the first instance? Won't people always react
to what they see and what they feel?
Pranami sector has been primarily divided into two separate sectors. Differences in thoughts and livelihood can be seen more or less between the two. The first sector is pre-dominantly well known in the Hindu society as "Shree Krishna Pranami Dharma" whereas the other sector only defines itself by its original name known by the name of "Nijanand Sampradaya" universally.
Let's address this burning issue firstly by analyzing "institutional strategy" from both sectors in the field. Let us try to answer these questions or try to seek answers of the following questions from religious leaders (or true followers) of both the sectors –
Q#. How do you identify yourself at first?
Q#. How do you then
approach to non-sundarsaath community (who are almost all the Hindus) for
transmitting Prannath's wisdom?
Q#. Do you not say that
Shri Devchandra was a humble devotee of Lord Krishna?
Q#. Do you not say that
Shri Prannath was the disciple of Lord Krishna?
Q#. In fact, how do you
even identify Lord Krishna?
Q#. In what ways is your
so called "Akshyarateet Krishna" special to other
"Krishnas" that you have categorised?
Q#. Do you in any ways
denounce or try to denounce "Krishna" worshiped by the Vaishnavas?
Q#. Do you use Prannath's
quotations to begin to justify your statements regarding Lord Krishna?
Q#. What do you wear as a
religious practitioner?
Q#.
Do you wear "janeu"?
Q#. How or what you really
want the community to perceive you by seeing them see you what you wear?
Q#. What is your mission
as a religious institution?
Q#. How is your religious
institution funded at the first place?
Q#. Do you take any
donations/charities from people of lower moral/religious character? (like meat
eaters, drunkards)
Q#. Do you criticize idol worshiping?
Q#. Do you privately
practice idol worshiping (opposite to what you say publicly to your community)?
Q#. Do you in any ways,
transgress or seek to oppress the poor and helpless in the name (and power) of
religious institution?
Q#. Are you open with your
ideologies?
Q#. If someone asks you
openly - "why do you speak on Islam if you are a Hindu?" then would
you lie openly or stay silent or do something else?
Q#. Do you celebrate Hindu
festivals? For example, if you celebrate Diwali then why do you
worship Laxmi (if you are not idol worshiper)? or if in case you don't worship
Laxmi, why is it necessary for you to even celebrate Diwali then (at the first
place)?
Q#. Do you want to live
being a social outcast or isolated?
Q#. In fact, is the non-Pranami community silently criticizing the entire Pranami sector as being Islamic in nature or being an outcasted version of Hinduism?
Q#. As a leader, do you
want anything from your followers? or what do you want your followers to be?
Q#. Does your
institutional strategy involve influencing hatred and bigotry towards others
(especially players on the extreme ends) to gain any sort of strategic
advantage?
Q#. What is your long-term
vision?
Q#. What are your
policies?
Q#. How have you aligned
your institutional policies with the broader Hindu community?
Q#. As being a highly
ranked spiritual/religious leader, have you ever had any criticism (ever risen
from Hindu community) as the result of your very own moral characters or
despicable actions?
Q#. Does you institution
desire monopoly (in practice)?
Q#.
Do you, in any ways, define "religion" and "religious
institution" as both being synonymous?
Q#. Do you
think that religion/spirituality is a business (it should be
industrialized)?
Q#. Do you
think that religion/spirituality is just a means of your survival?
Q#. Do you
take criticism as threat and simply like to avoid questions that question marks
your wrong behavior(if any)?
Q#.
Should we speak kindly and politely even though it's a lie?
Q#. What is
the punishment of quitting your religion/religious institution?
Q#. How do
you elaborate "Nijnaam"?
Q#. Do you
organize "Shreemad Bhagwad" programs? If yes, how and why?
Q#. Do you
follow and propagate caste system within your religious institution?
Q#. Are
your birth, marriage and death rituals different from the broader Hindu
community?
Q#. What is
"Mahaprasad"? Do you eat it? If yes, why is it necessary to
eat it?
Q#. Do you
see other religious institution (apart from yours) as your adversary?
Q#. Do you
knowingly distinguish between the poor and the riches and favor the ones with
greater socioeconomic status within your religious institution?
Q#. Can you
confirm with confidence that all of your followers (those in affiliation with
your religious institution) are - pure vegetarians, non-smokers, non-drinkers
and non-abusers of any substances?
Q#. Why do
some people perceive/see Pranami sector as a sub-sector erupting from
Vaishanavism?
Q#. What is
a "Kanthi"? Was it practiced or prescribed originally by Shri
Prannath ji as a part of accepting his faith? If not, then why is it in
prevalence?
Q#. Should
we listen to Hindu bhajans? (After all, some are really mesmerizing!)
Q#. Is it
forbidden to take offerings (or Prasad) of Hindu diety? What if
those offerings are totally pure (or satwik) to consume?
Q#. Why is there a
division of two factions if the mission of this sector is to unite people of
different religions?
Q#. Should
we follow religion based upon Shri Prannath's teachings/wisdom or should we
follow religious/spiritual leaders regardless of those original teachings?
Q#. Do you worship waani (shri kuljam Swaroop) or Shri Krishna
idol/images in temples/homes?
Q#. Have you hidden the real identity of Shri Prannath? Why/Why not?
Q#. Does your corresponding side has done better preaching (Jagani) than the
other? How?
Q#. How is Hindu religion (Sanataan Dharma) less good than your sector?
Q#. Do you wish to put an end to the eastern culture and tradition by
prioritizing Islamic concepts?
Q#. Is every Hindu scripture glorifying Lord Krishna? If yes, then have you supported/condemned
those scriptures to your favor?
Q#. Does the wisdom of Shri Prannath (or Tartam) needs to be proven via
the Hindu scriptures only? Do they have limitations if any?
Q#. Do you really want Shri Prannath's wisdom to flourish?
Q#. Do you condemn Krishna devotion (bhakti) and Krishna devotees (bhaktas) or atheism/atheists who do not have any devotions towards Lord Krishna?
Q#. Do you consider yourself as the chosen one or special than others?
Q#. Are you harming each other by any means necessary? Are you harming Hinduism
in that process?
Q#. What is your view on conversion of faith? Do you really want others readily to convert to your faith and vice-versa?
Q#. Why is
a religious/spiritual leader named "Shree Jagdish Chandra Ahuja" severely
hated and angered upon (as if he had stolen someone else's property) along with
his followers?
Q#. Can you
publicly state that you religion is Islam and your God is none other than Allah
and prophet Mohammed is his messenger?
Q#. Is your
God (Raj-ji) whom you all worship, different from each other? If not
then why do you treat people from the opposite faction as your radical
step-brother instead of treating as your own brother?
Q#. Will this unseen conflict between the two factions
of the entire Pranami community ever come to resolution?
Phew! That's plenty of
questions right there. I know these questions are tough and some of the leaders
may find it hard to swallow and may start playing blame games.
Now let’s start digging the answers. I will keep updating this post. Meanwhile,
share your thoughts by giving your valuable comments. I would like to invite
everyone out there for a meaningful discussion to the topics raised. If you
want to add few more questions, you’re most welcomed in that case. So, let’s
discuss.
Hello author!
ReplyDeleteI just came across your blog. The knowledge you've poured in your next blog "Sanandh" looks very promising. I've not read them all yet. But I'm sure I'll do it sometime, soon.
As you said above, "phew! that's plenty of questions right there." indeed. There are many questions to question and few questions to answer; all comes later. Firstly, I just look forward to your approach of answering your own question above, "Why is there a division into two factions if the mission of this sector is to unite people of different religions?" when the goal is one, the destination is one, and the very foundation of the sect is unity amongst all sect, "Sarva Dharma Samanvaya" then why such division again as "Shree Krishna Pranami Dharma" and "Nijanand Sampradaya"? What are those differences in thoughts and livelihoods, as you mentioned above, for instances? Where can I refer for the answer?
Thank you!